Essential Ingredients for Ninja Creami
Your complete shopping list! Quality ingredients make the difference between good and amazing ice cream. Here's what to stock in your kitchen.
Affiliate Disclosure
This post contains affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. This helps support our site and allows us to continue creating great content.
🎁 Beginner's Starter Kit
New to Ninja Creami? Start with these 5 essentials (under $100):
Heavy Cream
$9
Vanilla Extract
$16
Sugar
$5
Monk Fruit Sweetener
$12
Protein Powder
$40
Total: ~$82 for 50+ servings of ice cream!
Base Ingredients (Must-Have)
Essential basics for any recipe
Sweeteners & Flavorings
Control sweetness and enhance flavor
Pure Vanilla Extract (Madagascar)
$15.99Why: Enhances every recipe, pure taste
~50 recipes
View on AmazonFlavor Extracts Set (12-pack)
$29.99Why: Variety of flavors: almond, mint, coconut
~100 recipes
View on AmazonProtein & Healthy Options
For high-protein, low-calorie recipes
Fairlife Protein Shakes (12-pack)
$28.99Why: No mixing needed, perfect consistency
12 pints
View on AmazonChocolate & Mix-Ins
Add richness and texture
Texture Enhancers
Professional-level smoothness
Specialty Items
For unique and gourmet recipes
💰 Money-Saving Tips
Buy in Bulk
- ✓ Protein powder: Buy 5lb tubs (save 30%)
- ✓ Heavy cream: Buy 6-packs on sale
- ✓ Sweeteners: Large containers last months
- ✓ Vanilla: Buy pure extract in bulk
Smart Substitutions
- ✓ Half-and-half instead of heavy cream
- ✓ 2% milk instead of whole milk
- ✓ Store brand equals name brand
- ✓ Imitation vanilla for basic recipes
📦 Storage Tips
Dairy Products
Heavy cream lasts 2-3 weeks refrigerated. Freeze in ice cube trays for 3+ months. Milk: use within 7 days of opening.
Protein Powder
Store in cool, dry place. Lasts 1-2 years unopened, 6-12 months opened. Keep lid tight to prevent moisture.
Sweeteners & Extracts
Vanilla extract lasts indefinitely. Monk fruit sweetener: 2+ years. Store in pantry away from heat.
Mix-Ins
Chocolate chips: 1 year in pantry, 2+ in freezer. Nuts: freeze for freshness. Cookies: airtight container, 1-2 months.